The Supreme Court on Monday intervened to prohibit several FIRs lodged against Sanjay Kumar, co-director of the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies’ (CSDS) Lokniti programme, in response to his deleted tweets regarding voter discrepancies in the 2024 Maharashtra polls. The intervention comes amidst increased political controversy, with charges of disinformation and opposition-backed assaults on the Election Commission of India (ECI).
Kumar, a well-known psephologist who has spent decades studying Indian elections, had posted relative voter turnout figures for the Lok Sabha and Assembly polls conducted in Maharashtra in 2024. In one of his deleted tweets, he asserted that voter turnout in two constituencies, Devlali and Ramtek, fell by 36–38 per cent, while it increased by 47 per cent in Nashik West and 43 per cent in Hingna.
The tweets soon ignited political controversy. Opposition parties had used the facts to challenge the Election Commission’s handling of the election, accusing it of collusion with the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). BJP leaders retaliated against Kumar’s tweets, saying they were misleading and provided Congress and other opposition parties with ammunition to target the credibility of polling officials.
Reacting to this, Kumar removed the tweets and made a public apology, explaining that the mistakes had occurred due to a misinterpretation of the data by his team. “I apologize wholeheartedly for the tweets put out about Maharashtra elections. Mistake happened while crosschecking data of 2024 LS and 2024 AS. Our Data team misread the data in row. The tweet has been taken down.”. I did not intend to spread any kind of misinformation,” he posted on X (formerly Twitter).
Even after the apology, two FIRs were filed against Kumar — one in Nashik and one in Nagpur. The offenses listed included giving false information regarding the candidates during an election, the dissemination of false information, and defamation. The FIRs had the controversy surge to legal and political heights, with extensive debate on the accountability of researchers and commentators in the release of election-related information.
At Monday’s hearing at the Supreme Court, Kumar’s lawyer brought to notice the psephologist’s long service of three decades and unstained professional integrity. “He is a man of impeccable integrity. Three decades of diligent service to the country and the world. He is well respected. There was a lapse. He apologized. He erased and apologized publicly,” reasoned the lawyer, pointing out that Kumar’s intentions were never anything but good.
The Supreme Court’s stay of the FIRs indicates a sensitive handling of contentious issues at the boundary of political observation, research, and legal responsibility. Legal professionals argue that the action manifests the judiciary’s awareness of the distinction between intentional disinformation and genuine mistakes by respectable researchers.
Political responses were, however, sharply divided. BJP national spokesperson Shehzad Poonawalla lashed out against Kumar, saying, “Sanjay Kumar of CSDS admits his data on Maharashtra was fake. Based on this fakery, the Congress ecosystem attacked the ECI. Will the Congress apologise for insulting Maharashtra and its great people?”
Shanthi Kumar, BJP Telangana state treasurer, also commented on X, claiming that Kumar’s posts had given opposition parties a weapon to discredit the election authorities. “It gave Congress a weapon to attack election officials, and now you quietly want to slink away with an apology. Sorry, but your sorry won’t fix the harm!” she wrote, posting screenshots of the original and amended posts.
The row raises larger issues surrounding the sharing of electoral data and the role of psephologists and analysts. Although India has a rich history of election studies and independent political analysis, cases like these underscore the possibility for misinterpretation and politicization of data in intense political settings. They stress that even small mistakes, when magnified by political tales, can have disproportionate impacts on public perception and institution credibility.
For Sanjay Kumar, the incident is especially significant considering his long-standing image as an unbiased and strict researcher. His research at CSDS and Lokniti has influenced understanding of Indian voter conduct and election patterns for decades. The stay order from the Supreme Court provides him with some leeway to manoeuvre the legal predicament without compromising his professional integrity.
In the meantime, the political controversy around the Maharashtra voter turnout data remains on the boil. The Opposition parties stand accused of selectively citing the data to attack the Election Commission, even as the BJP positions the issue as an attempt to hatch a conspiracy of misinformation. The incident also points to the intensified scrutiny of election studies in India’s polarized political climate, where data-based analysis can swiftly become a battleground for partisanship.
Finally, the intervention by the Supreme Court brings relief to Sanjay Kumar temporarily, but the case itself indicates the fine balance between academic freedom, accountability in data dissemination, and political accountability. It is also a reminder of the stakes involved in analyzing and reporting election data in India, where even seasoned researchers may get caught in controversy owing to unintended mistakes. While FIRs are still pending, everyone’s attention will be on the changing legal process and the wider debates regarding transparency, reliability, and trust in election studies.
![]()

