The opposition of the Asia Internet Coalition, which represents major U.S. tech companies, to the Indian government’s proposal against dark patterns raises several important points and concerns. Dark patterns are deceptive practices used by online companies to manipulate consumers through unethical design or patterns in their online interfaces. Here are some key points from the article:
- Adverse Impact on Ease of Doing Business: The industry group argues that the Indian government’s proposal to regulate dark patterns could adversely affect the ease of doing business in the country. They suggest that the current self-regulatory framework should be the primary means of restricting the use of dark patterns.
- Regulatory Overlap: The Asia Internet Coalition points out that online platforms are already regulated in India under various existing laws, including the Information Technology Act 2000, the Consumer Protection Act 2019, and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023. They argue that introducing a separate regulatory framework for dark patterns would create unnecessary regulatory overlap and uncertainty.
- EU Approach: The industry group recommends that India consider adopting an approach similar to the European Union, which is also working on regulating dark patterns. They suggest that any new regulation should be sector and medium-agnostic and apply to both offline and online content and advertisements.
- Buffer Period: The group recommends providing a sufficient buffer period between the publication and implementation of the proposed rules, allowing companies time to adjust to the new regulations.
- Safe Harbor Protections: They request that safe harbor protections available in the IT Act should be maintained, and online intermediary platforms, including e-commerce marketplaces, should not be held responsible for dark patterns present in third-party content and advertisements hosted by them.
- Definition of “Endorser”: The group asks the consumer affairs department to define the term “endorser” in the rules to address instances of dark patterns through disguised advertisements, including endorsements from influencers and celebrities.
- Existing Laws and Practices: The group argues that many of the practices associated with dark patterns, such as false urgency, confirm shaming, and subscription traps, are already considered “unfair” under existing laws and internal policies of platforms and digital service providers.
- Digital India Act: The Indian government is planning to introduce the Digital India Act, which is expected to address concerns related to dark patterns, cybersecurity, data management, and emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence and blockchain.
Overall, this opposition from the Asia Internet Coalition highlights the complexities and challenges associated with regulating dark patterns in the digital economy, especially in a market as significant as India’s. The government will need to carefully consider these concerns while balancing the interests of consumers and businesses in its regulatory approach.
![]()

