The latest standoff centers on a WTO dispute settlement notice India submitted, accusing the U.S. of violating global trade norms through increased tariffs and what it calls “discriminatory trade barriers.” On Friday, the U.S. government formally dismissed India’s claims, stating the measures were lawful and necessary to protect domestic industries.
“The United States has acted in full compliance with WTO rules and will vigorously defend its trade policies,” a U.S. Trade Representative’s spokesperson told Reuters. “We do not recognize the validity of the claims laid out in India’s recent notice.”
India Eyes Retaliation as Options Narrow
In a swift response, India’s Ministry of Commerce and Industry indicated it is reviewing “all available options,” including reciprocal tariffs on select American goods or further escalation at the WTO. Commerce Secretary Sunil Barthwal hinted at countermeasures in a press briefing:
“India cannot accept unilateral trade restrictions that harm our economic interests. We are prepared to take proportionate action if necessary.”
— Sunil Barthwal, India’s Commerce Secretary
India may target U.S. exports such as agricultural products, automobiles, or high-tech equipment, sectors with significant bilateral trade volume. Officials are also exploring legal avenues within the WTO framework, although previous disputes have highlighted the organization’s limited enforcement capacity.
Flashpoint: Aluminum and Steel Tariffs
The immediate cause of the dispute is the Trump-era decision to impose tariffs of 25% on steel and 10% on aluminum imports, from which India was denied exemption. Despite ongoing negotiations, these duties remain in place under the Biden administration.
According to the Ministry of Commerce, Indian steel and aluminum exports to the U.S. were worth $1.8 billion in the previous fiscal year, while trade data show a rising U.S. trade deficit with India.
The USTR contends the tariffs are justified under national security provisions (Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act), a rationale India disputes as lacking legal merit under WTO rules.
Broader Context: Growing US-India Trade Friction
This episode is the latest in a series of trade disagreements. Previous flashpoints include India’s digital services taxes on technology giants, U.S. pressure on pharmaceutical patent protection, and disputes over agricultural imports.
Last year, several U.S. industry groups criticized India’s regulatory barriers, citing inconsistent standards for e-commerce, data localization mandates, and restrictions on American agricultural exports.
Despite an overall increase in diplomatic and defense cooperation, trade tensions have frequently strained the partnership. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, bilateral trade in goods reached a record $130 billion in 2023, with India enjoying a $40 billion surplus.
Reactions from Experts and Industry Bodies
Trade analysts warn that escalation could undermine broader economic and strategic cooperation. Dr. Arpita Mukherjee of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations states:
“Retaliatory tariffs would be a setback, but both sides know the value of keeping economic ties stable as they deepen their security partnership.”
The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) has urged both governments to resume talks and seek an amicable resolution to avoid harming businesses and consumers on both sides. Similarly, the U.S.-India Business Council called for “constructive engagement rather than punitive measures.”
What’s Next? Possible Implications and Path Forward
India has 60 days from the U.S. response to decide on a course of action. If negotiations falter, New Delhi could notify the WTO of its intent to impose retaliatory tariffs, a move permitted under the organization’s rules in cases of unremedied trade injury.
Experts note, however, that non-compliance by either side could weaken the rules-based order the WTO was meant to uphold. With disputes increasingly resolved outside of multilateral forums, the case underscores the organization’s shrinking influence.
As India weighs its options, many hope both countries will avoid escalation and instead pursue a negotiated settlement, reaffirming their commitment to fair trade and global economic stability.
![]()

