NEW!Upcoming Business Latest Interviews

World

Centre Flags Death Penalty in Aparajita Bill, Returns

3 Mins read

The Aparajita Women and Child Bill — the path-breaking legislation approved by the West Bengal Assembly in September 2024 — has run into a significant roadblock after the Centre raised an alarm on a crucial provision as being “excessively harsh and disproportionate.” The problematic provision? A clause that adds the death penalty or imprisonment for life until the completion of natural life for specific rape convictions.

West Bengal Governor C.V. Ananda Bose on Friday returned the Bill to the state government, citing “serious objections” entertained by the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA). Sources from the Raj Bhavan confirmed that the Governor has requested the state government to “appropriately reconsider” the contentious provisions in light of the Centre’s objections.

What is the Aparajita Bill?
The Aparajita Women and Child Bill, which has been welcomed by the state government as a forward-looking and bold step in addressing gender violence, intends to revise certain sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) — India’s newly revised criminal code. The Bill also intends to make the criminal code stricter against offenses such as rape, child abuse, and women and child trafficking.

Its most controversial clause suggests raising the minimum punishment for rape from 10 years to life imprisonment until death, with the option of the death sentence in extreme cases. The Bill also suggests establishing fast-track courts, special victim support services, and tighter procedural guidelines to hasten convictions.

Why Has the Centre Objected?
Following sources well within the Raj Bhavan, the Ministry of Home Affairs has “marked several provisions” in the Bill as inconsistent with the principles of proportional justice. The Centre’s most fundamental objection is with the addition of death penalty and life imprisonment until natural death for a wider range of sexual offences — sanctions it considers “excessively harsh,” particularly in a legal system where comparable offenses are heard under a common national regime.

“The BNS has only recently come into force as a modernized substitute for the IPC. States attempting to modify its provisions will have to do so with extreme care,” a senior MHA official is said to have conveyed. “Excessive punishment can even infringe constitutional guarantees regarding fair trial and humane sentencing.”

This scrutiny by the Centre reflects a wider policy predilection for uniform criminal justice standards across the country, and a resistance to state-level divergence when it comes to penal law.

The Role of Governors
Governor C.V. Ananda Bose, as the state’s constitutional head and representative of the central government, has an important role to play in legislative assent. While he had previously withheld assent to the Aparajita Bill on technical grounds, this is the first time that the Bill is being sent back to the state assembly officially on substantive grounds.

“Governor has responded to the feedback he has received from the Ministry of Home Affairs and has asked the state government to clear these objections first before the Bill is resent for assent,” the Raj Bhavan official said.

Under Article 200 of the Indian Constitution, the Governor can reserve a Bill (except a money Bill) for reconsideration by the state legislature, if he feels it is required. If the legislature sends the Bill again, with or without amendments, the Governor is constitutionally obligated to accord assent — unless he prefers to reserve the Bill for the consideration of the President.

State Government’s Response
Even as the storm is brewing over the Bill, the state government seems clueless about the Centre’s objections. Responding to a statement on Friday afternoon, a senior state official stated, “We have no official communication in writing from either the Governor’s office or Central Government about any objections to the Aparajita Bill.”

The minister asserted that the Bill had been prepared following extensive legal consultation and public feedback and its provisions were in consonance with the duty of the state to provide a safe and just atmosphere for women and children.

Experts in law, though, warn that the state needs to be cautious. “Although criminal law is in the Concurrent List, both the Centre and states can enact laws, state amendments that go against central legislation or are against constitutional provisions can be invalidated,” opined retired Calcutta High Court judge Justice A.K. Banerjee. “The Centre’s resistance will now compel the state to go back to the details.”

Political Fallout
The revival of the Aparajita Bill has already created political waves in West Bengal. Opposition BJP leaders have welcomed the Governor’s move, accusing the TMC government of high-handedness.

“The TMC attempted to push through a Bill without adequate legal scrutiny. The Centre has acted rightly to stop miscarriage of justice,” BJP spokesperson Samik Bhattacharya said.

By contrast, TMC leaders have charged the BJP-led Centre with “playing politics over women’s safety.”

“If the Centre is so worried about women’s rights, it should start by explaining why conviction rates in rape cases are abysmal all over India,” said TMC MP Saugata Roy. “The Aparajita Bill is a step forward, not back.”

What Next?
The ball is thus in the court of the state government. It can either accept the Centre’s suggestions and weaken the stricter provisions of the Bill — particularly the death sentence — or re-enact the original version in the state assembly.

In that event, Governor Bose can reserve the Bill for Presidential assent, with a longer constitutional and political exercise to follow.

For the present, the fate of the Aparajita Bill — and West Bengal’s bold effort to establish a new standard for gender justice — remains uncertain.

Related posts
BusinessMarketsTechnologyWorld

Samsung Launches Galaxy Z TriFold: The Foldable Phone That Becomes a Tablet

4 Mins read
Samsung Introduces Galaxy Z TriFold, Its First-Ever Multi-Folding Smartphone Samsung is taking foldable phones to the next level. After years of hints,…
World

Gurugram BTech Student Found Dead in Hostel Room

4 Mins read
Gurugram, 26 August 2025 — In a shocking tragedy that has rocked the student community, 23-year-old third-year BTech student Bhumika Gupta from…
World

Xi Hosts Putin, Modi Amid Trump’s Tariff Threats

4 Mins read
With tensions between the United States and a number of key world economies continuing to build, Chinese leader Xi Jinping will host…
Power your team with InHype

Add some text to explain benefits of subscripton on your services.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *